Judge Rejects Poultry Settlement

A federal judge has rejected a request to set aside his earlier judgment against poultry companies, finding a proposed settlement with Oklahoma would not adequately address pollution in the Illinois River watershed.

U.S. District Judge Gregory Frizzell’s November 18 ruling blocks a necessary step for the agreement to take effect. Attorney General Gentner Drummond and the poultry companies had jointly sought to replace the December 2025 judgment with the negotiated settlement.

The agreement included approximately $41.7 million for environmental work and legal expenses, along with separate funding for penalties and compliance monitoring. It also called for restrictions on poultry litter application over seven years.

Frizzell found the agreement lacked clear safeguards for how the environmental money would be spent and did not ensure that litter restrictions would sufficiently reduce phosphorus pollution. He also warned that inadequate funding could leave Oklahoma taxpayers responsible for monitoring and other costs.

The judge said seven years was insufficient to address pollution that could take decades to resolve. His earlier judgment established a 30-year cleanup framework with court oversight and restrictions based on phosphorus levels in the soil.

Representative David Hardin expressed disappointment with the decision and concern about its impact on poultry producers.

“It’s disappointing to see another setback in a case that has already gone on for more than 20 years,” Hardin said. “This directly affects their livelihoods and the communities they call home.”

Hardin said he remains hopeful for a resolution that protects natural resources while providing stability for people who depend on poultry production.

Frizzell also criticized the companies for prolonging the litigation and said the timing of the state’s settlement decision suggested “the influence of political pressures over substance.”

The earlier judgment remains in place, but its enforcement was paused by the Tenth Circuit pending further action. Frizzell’s latest order does not lift that pause or end the appeals.


Print pagePDF pageEmail page

*

Copyright © The McCarville Report